By Lisa M. Belisle, MD, MPH
Originally published March/April 2011, Parent & Family
It has been said that all mothers are working mothers. This is certainly the case. Mothers are incredibly important. At the risk of offending my feminist friends (or fathers, for that matter), I’m going to suggest that mothers are the lynchpin of the family. They tend to be the ones who keep things together; make sure things are done. This is the case regardless of whether they choose to stay home with their children, or have outside careers. Moms just get it done.
(By the way, fathers are equally important, in their own very special way. But this column is dedicated to mothers. Dads, you’ll get your turn.)
A few months ago I had an important conversation with a woman I had only just met. After recognizing me as a Parent & Family contributor, she told me she had begun reading Dr. Lisa/Dr. Mom (November/December 2010) but couldn’t bring herself to finish it. After scanning a few sentences, she thought I was going to talk about how I had tried to juggle working and medicine, but ultimately decided it was impossible and chose instead to stay home with the kids full time.
I didn’t, of course, which became clear as the article progressed. My choice was indeed to continue engaging in the juggling act. I had many reasons for this--I liked being a doctor, we needed to pay back our professional school debt, etc. Equally as fulfilling may have been the stay-at-home-mother route, but it wasn’t the direction I went in.
Why didn’t this woman want to read about the stay-at-home route? Because she had taken the have-a-career-outside-the-home route and was finding it incredibly challenging. She was desperately seeking a way to make it tenable, and couldn’t bear to read another story that denied this possibility.
She wanted to hear information that supported her situation.
We all want to hear information that supports our situation. So, today, I will offer you some. I offer this information to all mothers, of all sorts: stay-at-home, career-outside-the-home and every variation in between.
The information I have to offer is this: IF we are mothers, we are ALL working, MOST, if not ALL, of the time. The way we choose to work is the only thing that divides us. And, really, it shouldn’t. We should support one another in whatever choices we make. We should support one another because we know that working is hard, no matter where it is done; mothering is hard, no matter how it is done.
I have been a doctor for almost fifteen years, and a mother for seventeen. During that time I have cared for mothers across the spectrum: every age, every approach to working. I have seen happy career moms and happy home moms. I have seen miserable versions of each of those as well.
The difference between the happy and the miserable moms? Their commitment to going in either direction. The only way to be a happy mother, of any variety, is to be happy with how you mother. If it makes you happier to stay home, please do so. If it makes you happier not to, please don’t.
Why? Because miserable mothers make miserable children. We spend our lives telling our children that we want them to be happy. If we aren’t happy ourselves, what message are we sending?
There should be no value judgement associated with staying at home, or not. Mothers are, first and foremost, people. People learn in different ways; they love in different ways. They are intellectually, physically, emotionally and socially stimulated in different ways. If, in order to be stimulated, you must work, that’s OK. Likewise, if you would rather stay at home, that’s OK, too. Either approach--if done in a balanced, reasonable manner--will yield balanced, reasonable children.
Honoring ourselves, and the way in which we learn and love, is the best thing we can do for our children. Our children learn best by watching us. If they see us honoring ourselves, they will honor themselves as well. They will trust themselves. They will value themselves.
Then, someday, they will teach their children to do the same.
And that, my fellow home and career moms, is the only information you need to support your situation.
Believe me, I’m a mother. I know how things work.